Saturday, January 2, 2016

Greek to Gaucho: Easy and Inspired Argentine Empanadas stuffed with Cincinnati Chili

For all of you who know and love Jared you know he is a very dedicated person. Dedicated to his family, his job and...Cincinnati style chili! You can take the kid out of Cincinnati but you can not take the Cincinnati out of the kid. For as long as I have known him he has espoused his true love for the various ways one can fix this delicacy, be it a '3-way', '4-way', 'cheese coney' or that heavy-weight champ of party appetizers, the Chili Dip. His unwavering devotion remains for this rather unsightly Chili even all the way down here in Argentina. Jared follows Skyline Chili (one of the two local Cincinnati Chili Parlor Chains) on social media only to cry out in agony when they post a 'delicious' photo of a cheese coney on game day at Great American Ballpark. We have had to have family members send us chili or sherpa it to us in their suitcases in the various locations we have lived.


Where did this strange phenomenon known as Cincinnati style chili come from you may ask? It arrived to Southern Ohio in the first half of the twentieth century in the secret recipe books of some Greek immigrant families. While the area is still dotted with small mom-and-pop chili parlors, today the most ubiquitous brands are Skyline Chili and Gold Star Chili. It may seem strange to outsiders but locals eat this beanless, slightly spicy chili on top of spaghetti or completely covering a stubby hotdog. Either way, it is topped with a mound of finely shredded cheddar cheese and eaten about once a week.

But why empanadas? Having lived in Argentina for almost two years, Jared and I have both developed a healthy affinity for the glorious, hand-held savory pie known as an empanada. Now, Argentines did not invent the empanada (most probably the Spanish stole it from the Moors during the Inquisition and then brought it over here to South America. Some sources even credit the Greeks, with their filo dough, as the original inventors of empanadas) but in my opinion the Argentines have perfected it! There are many different types of fillings (meat, ham and cheese, chicken, etc) and styles of closing the empanadas (there is even a term in Spanish for it: repulgue). Each region has a specialty and each considers theirs to be the best, surprise surprise! You can also find empanadas in most other South American countries. We have had delicious ones in Colombia, Ecuador and Chile--but you know as an 'adopted Argentine' I love theirs the best;)

Here is the typical Argentine empanada, cooked in a clay oven.

Because of their versatility, empanadas are the perfect vessel for Cincinnati Chili. After Jared said he thought it might be tasty to make a Cincy Chili Empanada, we spent some time in the kitchen figuring out the best way to marry the two. After an evening playing around with different meat to liquid ratios, I think we came out with something pretty yummy...a perfect homage to Cincinnati and Argentina! Feel free to use our easy recipe and then check out the pictures of how our first experiment turned out while making them.

THE RECIPE!
Ingredients (makes 16 Empanadas)
1 2 oz packet of Cincinnati Chili Mix
1 4 oz of canned tomato paste
1 pound of lean ground beef
4 cups of water
1 bag mild cheddar cheese cubes
1 bag finely shredded mild cheddar cheese
1 pack of Goya empanada “discos” or similar
1 onion
1 egg

1. Mix the Chili Mix packet, tomato paste and 4 cups of water in a large saucepot. Note that the amount of water added is 2/3 of the normal required to make the regular chili recipe, because you need the empanada filling to be less watery than the normal chili. Heat on stove at medium.

2. Brown the ground beef in a sauté pan mixed with a handful of onions. Once browned, strain the fat from the beef before adding it to the sauce pot.

3. Cover the saucepot now containing the beef and chili- our chili stuffing- to a rolling boil for 3 minutes.

4. Uncover the pot, reduce heat to medium and simmer for approximately 25-30 minutes while stirring. Once the chili stuffing has arrived to be the consistency of a Texas-style chili or ‘Sloppy Joe’ mix, it is ready to be cooled.

5. Remove the chili stuffing from saucepot and transfer to another bowl to permit cooling for around 15 minutes.

6. Preheat the oven to 400 degrees.

7. Grease an oven pan.

8. Once the chili stuffing has cooled down enough to handle, make the empanadas. Remove the empanada “disco” dough and put one in your hand. Scoop two large tablespoons of chili stuffing into the disco, and then put one cheddar cheese cube in as well.

9. Use your finger to wet the edge of the empanada dough where the fold will meet, in order to allow the dough to stick together when you close it. Close the empanada dough to create the empanada, using your fingers to press at the center first and then down each side to the corner.

10. Once the dough is pressed together and closed, it’s time to get creative and practice your Argentine empanada folding skills. With your fingertips, fold the edge over itself every quarter inch or so.

11. Place the stuffed and folded empanadas on the oven pan.

12. After all the empanadas are finished, create and ‘egg wash’ to put on the empanadas before you put them in the oven. This will help brown the empanadas. Put an egg white into a bowl and put in one teaspoon of water. Then brush on this mixture onto the tops of the empanadas.

13. Place a pinch of shredded cheddar onto each empanada.

14. Cook in the oven for around 10 minutes, or until the empanadas are golden brown.

15. Allow the empanadas to cool a bit before eating, and enjoy!

HOW WE DID IT!


Before you start, you need a key ingredient, empanada dough rounds, or discos. Luckily here in Argentina, you can get these easily at any corner grocery or supermarket. But in the US it might be a little more difficult. If you live in a big city, you might have to search to find them at a Latin American specialty grocery. But now that there is more Latin influence in the beautiful melting pot of our great USA (remember immigrants brought Cincy Chili over in the first place!), stores like WalMart, Wegman’s and Shoprite carry the Goya brand empanada rounds.

Here are our ingredients. We used a Gold Star Chili mix packet, but you could also probably use a can of another brand if you'd like, it would just take longer to boil off the water to get the correct consistency.

Once you start the recipe and are waiting for the Chili to simmer, make sure you open up some famous Argentina Malbec wine to sip on. It is illegal to make empanadas without a little Malbec to go along with it! You can get a tasty Malbec at any supermarket in the US for less than $15 dollars.

We decided to make half the recipe for 8 empanadas, and use the other half of the packet to make regular Cincy Chili for a 3-Way to go with our empanadas. You can clearly see the difference in the normal recipe on the right compared to the empanada chili stuffing on the left, thanks to the 1/3 less water.

Here's the final consistency of the empanada chili stuffing. It turned out spicy, at least to what we are used to down here in Argentina where they don't really eat spicy food.

After the chili stuffing cooled down, we worked together to stuff the empanadas with the chili and cheese cubes. I have a little experience with this from my Argentine cooking lessons, but at first it is a bit of challenge to get them looking good. By the end we had perfected the close and fold.
Filling the empanada.
Use a bit of water to line the edge where you will close the empanada.
The first 'closure' fold.
The final fold, or 'repulgue.'
Prepping the egg wash.
Yes the empanadas have a cheddar cheese cube inside, perfect to melt while baking. But with Cincy Chili I've learned there is no such thing as too much cheese, so we added a pinch on top after the egg wash before we put them in the oven. Since they don't have shredded cheddar and real mild cheddar is hard to come by, we just used a three cheese mix that included cheddar.
Here is the final product! The cheese on top crisped up into a delicious Cheez-It like crunch.
We also went with the tried and true 3-Way Chili Spaghetti, just in case our empanadas turned out to be a disaster. And Malbec of course!

THE FINAL VERDICT!
This Cincinnati Kid approves. We both liked the empanadas a lot. Because there was less water, the chili stuffing turned out to be concentrated and spicier than normal chili like on the 3-Way. The cheese crisps on top also were good. Another plus for Cincy chili lovers is that you will probably have leftovers to take on the go the next day. Instead of having to put together a 3-Way or cheese coney, just pop the empanada into the oven or microwave and you have the Cincy chili flavor without all the work, or the need for silverware.

A gaucho might not approve of our spicy chili stuffing, but we enjoyed making a fusion of one of our hometown traditions from the other side of the world, combined with the famous local cuisine. Since the purpose of the Olmsted Scholarship is to immerse in all aspects of the culture, food and meals are several of the best ways to get to know a land and its people. Also, it was a great reminder to trace the origin of Cincy Chili and empanadas, almost back to the same place in Greece! In one way or another all of us, our ancestors and our traditions are immigrants from somewhere else, an important reminder in these turbulent times.

We read online that we could also make healthier chili with turkey instead of ground beef. On the other end of the spectrum, we thought we could fry the empanadas instead of baking them in the oven... because what isn't better fried!?! Do you have any good Cincy chili or other local recipes that you can't live without? Let us know!